
SecN.79290 (Customer) asked a question.
Using an established Windows desktopMFA app integration, I configured two separate Yubikey 5C's (Non-NFC/bluetooth) with two separate accounts/workstations, but we are not being give the option to use the yukikey for MFA during sign in.
Rules have Yubikey as MFA, both workstations have all required registry keys (including AllowedFactors, UserDirectAuth (1)).
Coworker was able to add the security key to their Okta Verify desktop app as an offline TOTP and it worked, but no documentation that I have found shows that. So, that's great for that one workstation, but we still cannot take that Yubikey to other workstations and use it with onlinefactor without setting it up as a method in the desktop app of another workstation (assuming we do not have our account loaded on the PC).

Hello @SecN.79290 (Customer) Thank you for posting on our Community page!
If the Yubikey was not properly setup it could cause an issue and not have it prompt as an MFA. Please make sure that all the right steps were done:
https://help.okta.com/en-us/content/topics/security/mfa/yubikey.htm
Additionally you can also review the System Log to see if you have anything there that could point to the issue.
Thank you for reaching out to our Community and have a great day!
--
Help others in the community by liking or hitting Select as Best if this response helped you.
The new Okta Help Center YouTube channel is your go-to resource for tips, troubleshooting, and best practice videos. Subscribe today.
Hey @Paul S. (Okta, Inc.)
We have followed both the Okta and Yubico docs pertaining to configuring our Yubikey 5C (non-NFC) keys. Uploaded the seed files to Okta tenant, assigned keys to users, added the additional registry keys included in the documentation for "allowed factors" and "directauth." Configured the rules in the tenant around the desktop MFA application to include Yubikey, but still - when a user signs in and is prompted by Okta, and they choose "try another way" - the yubikey is not an option.
Additionally, the key to the workstation Okta Verify application as an offline TOTP. But there is still no option for "online" authentication using the key.
Your assistance is greatly appreciated, Paul! Thanks.
Hello @SecN.79290 (Customer) I would recommend to open a case with Support, as this requires additional investigation, and a technical engineer would be able to have access to additional tools to get to the bottom of this.
Thank you for reaching out to our Community and have a great day!
--
Help others in the community by liking or hitting Select as Best if this response helped you.
The new Okta Help Center YouTube channel is your go-to resource for tips, troubleshooting, and best practice videos. Subscribe today.